The full-to-full method
The pump tells you exactly how much fuel you burned only when the tank goes back to the same level it started at. Full is the one level you can reach every time, so measure between two full fills:
- Fill the tank until the pump clicks off, and write down the odometer reading.
- Drive as usual.
- Fill to full again. Write down the odometer and the gallons you pumped.
- Subtract the first odometer reading from the second to get the miles, and divide by the gallons from step 3.
MPG = miles since the last full fill ÷ gallons pumped to refill the tank
The gallons from the first fill don't count. They replaced fuel you burned before you started measuring.
Why per-fill math breaks
The tempting shortcut is to divide each fill's miles by that fill's gallons. That only works when every fill is a full one and none are missing.
Partial fills
If you stop at half a tank, the gallons you pumped are less than the fuel you burned since the last fill. Dividing by them gives a number that is far too high. The next full fill then has to make up the difference, and comes out far too low.
The fix: don't calculate at a partial fill. Add its gallons to a running total, and calculate at the next full fill using all the gallons since the last full one.
Missed fill-ups
If you forget to write down a fill, the next one you do record covers the miles for two tanks but only the gallons for one. That is how a car that gets 28 MPG shows a 50 MPG tank.
The fix: when you know you missed one, throw that stretch away and start measuring fresh from your next full fill. The My MPG tool on fueleconomy.gov asks for a "gap" record for the same reason.
A worked example
Three fill-ups, with a partial fill in the middle:
| Fill | Odometer | Gallons | Filled to full? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 41,200 | 11.8 | Yes |
| 2 | 41,480 | 6.0 | No, partial |
| 3 | 41,710 | 12.5 | Yes |
Per-fill math gets it wrong. Fill 2: 280 miles ÷ 6.0 gallons = 46.7 MPG. Fill 3: 230 miles ÷ 12.5 gallons = 18.4 MPG. Neither is real.
Full to full gets it right. From fill 1 to fill 3 the car went 41,710 − 41,200 = 510 miles. Refilling took 6.0 + 12.5 = 18.5 gallons. 510 ÷ 18.5 = 27.6 MPG. Fill 1's 11.8 gallons are left out: that fuel was burned before the measurement started.
Suppose the next fill you record is a full one at 42,300 with 11.0 gallons, but you forgot to log a fill around 42,000. Per-fill math says 590 ÷ 11.0 = 53.6 MPG. Leave that stretch out and start measuring again from 42,300.
In metric, divide liters by kilometers and multiply by 100: the same tank is 70.0 L over 820.8 km, about 8.5 L/100 km.
How Fillwise handles this
Fillwise is an Android app, now in Closed Alpha, that does this math for every tank.
- Quick to log. Enter the odometer, then any two of fuel amount, price, and total. Fillwise works out the third.
- Filled to full. Leave it on for a full tank. Turn it off for a partial fill, and it rolls into the next full tank. The Tanks tab lists each partial fill with the tank it rolled into.
- I skipped logging a fill-up. Check it when you missed one, and the gap won't show up as a fake high MPG. That stretch is left out, and a new tank starts from that fill-up if you filled to full, or from your next full fill if you didn't.
- Every tank, measured. Each full-to-full tank shows its distance, fuel, economy, and how it compares to your normal. Partial fills logged before your first full fill aren't counted, because there is nothing to measure them against.
- Your units. MPG (US), MPG (UK), L/100 km, or km/L, with miles or kilometers and US gallons, UK gallons, or liters.
Once it knows your normal, Fillwise also tells you when mileage drops and stays down. Before you worry about a low number, read did your gas mileage really drop?
Sources
- fueleconomy.gov: My MPG Help