Fuel economy, explained

Did your gas mileage really drop?

One low tank is rarely a problem. A drop that holds for several tanks in a row is worth a closer look. Here is how to tell the two apart, what usually causes a real drop, and what to have checked when the everyday causes don't explain it.

One bad tank is usually noise

The number you get for a single tank depends on a lot of things that have nothing to do with the health of your car.

  • Partial fills. If you stopped before the pump clicked off, the gallons you paid for don't match the miles you drove since the last fill. That tank can come out far too high, and the next one far too low. How to calculate MPG correctly walks through the math.
  • Where the pump shuts off. "Full" is not an exact level. Nozzles click off at slightly different points from pump to pump, so one tank can take a little more or less fuel than the miles alone would explain. The next full tank evens it out.
  • A one-off week. A road trip at highway speed, a weekend of towing, a heavy load, or a tank of stop-and-go traffic can move one tank a long way. Mileage usually falls off quickly above 50 mph, and aggressive driving alone can cost 10% to 40% in stop-and-go traffic.

What makes a drop real

A real drop persists. Compare the average of your last few full tanks with your typical tanks from before. If one tank comes in low and the next is back to normal, that was noise. If three tanks in a row land well below where you used to be, something changed: the weather, how you drive, or the car.

Judge the trend over several tanks, each measured from one full tank to the next, not any single number.

Common causes that aren't a fault

Most lasting drops have an everyday explanation. Rule these out before you book a shop visit.

Winter-blend fuel and cold weather

Winter grades of gasoline can carry slightly less energy per gallon than summer blends. The cold itself costs more: fueleconomy.gov reports that a typical gasoline car's city mileage is about 15% lower at 20°F than at 77°F, and as much as 24% lower on short trips of 3 to 4 miles. Ethanol content matters too: E10 typically gets 3% to 4% fewer miles per gallon than ethanol-free gasoline, and E15 4% to 5% fewer. A seasonal drop should come back in spring.

Short trips and cold starts

An engine uses extra fuel until it warms up, and on a short trip it may never get there. Warming the car up by idling makes this worse, because idling gets zero miles per gallon; most manufacturers say to drive off gently after about 30 seconds. If your routine has shifted toward short hops, your average will drop with it.

Tire pressure

Tire pressure falls as the weather cools, and soft tires roll with more resistance. Under-inflation costs about 0.2% of your mileage for every 1 psi drop in the average pressure of all four tires. Check them cold and set them to the pressure on the sticker in the driver's door jamb or in the owner's manual, not the maximum printed on the tire.

Air conditioning

In very hot weather, running the AC can cut a conventional car's fuel economy by more than 25%, and the effect is largest on short trips.

Extra weight and roof racks

An extra 100 pounds in the car can cost about 1% in MPG. A large, blunt roof-top cargo box can cost around 2% to 8% in city driving, 6% to 17% on the highway, and 10% to 25% at 65 to 75 mph; rear-mounted carriers cost less. A rack or box left on since the last trip counts.

Mechanical causes worth having checked

If none of the above explains it and the drop has held for several tanks, have the car looked at. These are things a mechanic will typically look at. They are places to start, not a diagnosis: only an inspection can tell you which, if any, applies to your car.

  • The check-engine light and stored codes. If the light is on, start there. A shop can read the codes the engine computer has stored.
  • Oxygen sensors. The engine computer uses them to set the fuel mixture, so a mechanic will check that they are reading and responding normally.
  • A dragging brake. A caliper that doesn't fully release keeps working against the car. One wheel running much hotter than the others after a drive is the usual sign a mechanic will look for.
  • Cooling system and thermostat. An engine that never reaches its normal temperature runs as if every trip were a cold start.
  • Tires and alignment. Uneven wear and alignment are part of a normal inspection.
  • Recent service. If the drop started right after an oil change, ask what went in. Using 5W-30 in an engine designed for 5W-20 can lower gas mileage by 1% to 1.5%.

If the drop is large and sudden, or the car runs rough, stalls, or smells of fuel, don't wait for more tanks of data. Have it checked now.

How Fillwise watches for a drop

Fillwise is an Android app, now in Closed Alpha, that does this comparison for you. It measures economy from one full tank to the next, so a partial fill is counted with the next full tank instead of skewing the numbers. It needs 9 full tanks to know your normal. After that it compares your last 3 full tanks with the 6 before them, and when the last 3 average 6% or more below, it shows a mileage drop alert.

The alert shows the numbers behind it and a bar chart of those tanks. It lists the usual suspects to rule out first (winter-blend fuel, shorter and colder trips, tire pressure), then things to check, cheapest first, with your service history next to the ones you have logged. In the app's own words, it can tell you something changed, not what.

  • I know why. Tell it the reason: winter fuel or cold weather, different driving lately, or something else. The alert goes quiet, not away. It comes back if mileage drops another 3%, or if it hasn't recovered after 6 more tanks.
  • I fixed something. Log the repair, and after 3 tanks Fillwise tells you whether mileage came back.

It also keeps your service schedule, and everything stays on your phone. To get the tank math right before any of this, see how to calculate MPG correctly.

Sources

Closed Alpha

Let Fillwise watch your mileage.

Fillwise is in a closed test on Google Play. Join, log your real fill-ups, and tell us what works and what doesn't. Everyone in the Closed Alpha gets premium free when it launches.